Skip to main content Skip to main navigation menu Skip to site footer

Perbandingan penanganan operatif dengan non operatif pada tatalaksana dislokasi bahu anterior terhadap rekurensi: systematic review


Background: Shoulder dislocations are very prone to recurrent shoulder dislocations, the best treatment for reducing recurrence is controversial in several studies. Thus, the aim of this study was to compare operative and nonoperative management of anterior dislocation of the shoulder against recurrence.

Method: The literature search used PubMed and Google Scholar databases and met the inclusion criteria from 2010-2020 regarding the comparison of operative and non-operative treatment on anterior shoulder dislocation on recurrence. This systematic review was prepared by using the PRISMA protocol (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyzes).

Result: Five studies were reviewed with a total sample size of 635 samples. Three studies stated that the recurrence rate for operative was 10-13% and non-operative was 41-71% and there was a significant difference. Meanwhile, two other studies stated that there was no significant difference between operative and non-operative on recurrence rates.

Conclusion: Studies suggest that non-operative management recurs more frequently in shoulder dislocation than operative management.


Pendahuluan: Dislokasi bahu sangat rentan untuk terjadi dislokasi bahu berulang (recurrent). Hingga saat ini, penanganan yang terbaik dalam menurunkan rekurensi masih bersifat kontroversial dalam beberapa studi. Untuk itu, tujuan dari studi ini adalah untuk membandingan penanganan operatif dengan non operatif pada tatalaksana dislokasi bahu anterior terhadap rekurensi

Metode: Pencarian literatur menggunakan database PubMed dan Google Scholar, serta memenuhi kriteria inklusi dari tahun 2010-2020 mengenai perbandingan operatif dan non operatif pada dislokasi bahu anterior terhadap rekurensi. Penulian systematic review ini disusun menggunakan protocol PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses). 

Hasil: Lima studi yang diulas dengan jumlah sampel sebanyak 635 sampel. Tiga studi menyebutkan recurrence rate pada operatif sebesar 10-13% dan non operatif sebesar 41-71% dan terjadi perbedaan yang signifikan. Sedangkan, dua studi lainnya menyebutkan recurrence rate pada operatif dan non operatif menunjukkan tidak ada perbedaan yang signifikan.

Kesimpulan: Keseluruhan studi menyebutkan bahwa penanganan non operatif lebih sering mengalami rekurensi pada dislokasi bahu dibandingkan dengan penanganan operatif.


  1. Setiawan, A. 2011. Faktor Timbulnya Cedera Olahraga. [online] Available at: [Accessed 4 November 2020]
  2. Braun, C. and McRobert, C., 2019. Conservative management following closed reduction of traumatic anterior dislocation of the shoulder. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews,
  3. Rosa, J., Checchia, C. and Miyazaki, A., 2020. Traumatic Anterior Instability Of The Shoulder. Revista Brasileira de Ortopedia.
  4. Bonazza, N. and Riboh, J., 2020. Management of Recurrent Anterior Shoulder Instability After Surgical Stabilization in Children and Adolescents. CurrentReviews in Musculoskeletal Medicine, 13(2), pp.164-172.
  5. Hasebroock, A., Brinkman, J., Foster, L. and Bowens, J., 2019. Management of primary anterior shoulder dislocations: a narrative review. Sports Medicine Open, 5(1).
  6. Shah, F. and Ali, M., 2020. First time traumatic anterior shoulder dislocation: Will it always result in recurrent shoulder dislocation in all patients?. The Professional Medical Journal, 27(04), pp.695-699.
  7. Olds, M., Ellis, R., Donaldson, K., Parmar, P. and Kersten, P., 2015. Risk factors which predispose first-time traumatic anterior shoulder dislocations to recurrent instability in adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 49(14), pp.913-922.
  8. King, S. and Cowling, P. 2018. Management of first time shoulder dislocation. Elsevier.
  9. White, A., Patel, N., Hadley, C. and Dodson, C., 2019. An Algorithmic Approach to the Management of Shoulder Instability. JAAOS: Global Research and Reviews, 3(12), pp.e19.00168.
  10. Mahure, S., Mollon, B., Capogna, B., Zuckerman, J., Kwon, Y. and Rokito, A., 2018. Risk factors for recurrent instability or revision surgery following arthroscopic Bankart repair. The Bone & Joint Journal, 100-B(3), pp.324-330.
  11. Franklin, C. and Weiss, J., 2019. The Natural History of Pediatric and Adolescent Shoulder Dislocation. Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics, 39, pp.S50-S52.
  12. Zaremski, J., Galloza, J., Sepulveda, F., Vasilopoulos, T., Micheo, W. and Herman, D., 2016. Recurrence and return to play after shoulder instability events in young and adolescent athletes: a systematic review and meta-analysis. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 51(3), pp.177-184.
  13. Chapus, V., Rochcongar, G., Pineau, V., Salle de Chou, É. and Hulet, C., 2015. Ten-year follow-up of acute arthroscopic Bankart repair for initial anterior shoulder dislocation in young patients. Orthopaedics & Traumatology: Surgery & Research, 101(8), pp.889-893.
  14. Hughes, J., Bastrom, T., Pennock, A. and Edmonds, E., 2018. Arthroscopic Bankart Repairs With and Without Remplissage in Recurrent Adolescent Anterior Shoulder Instability With Hill-Sachs Deformity. Orthopaedic Journal of Sports Medicine, 6(12), p.232596711881398.
  15. Kramer, J., Gajudo, G. and Pandya, N., 2019. Risk of Recurrent Instability After Arthroscopic Stabilization for Shoulder Instability in Adolescent Patients. Orthopaedic Journal of Sports Medicine, 7(9), p.232596711986899.
  16. De Carli, A., Vadalà, A., Lanzetti, R., Lupariello, D., Gaj, E., Ottaviani, G., Patel, B., Lu, Y. and Ferretti, A., 2019. Early surgical treatment of first-time anterior glenohumeral dislocation in a young, active population is superior to conservative management at long-term follow-up. International Orthopaedics, 43(12), pp.2799-2805.
  17. Gigis, I., Heikenfeld, R., Kapinas, A., Listringhaus, R. and Godolias, G., 2014. Arthroscopic Versus Conservative Treatment of First Anterior Dislocation of the Shoulder in Adolescents. Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics, 34(4), pp.421-425.
  18. LeClere, L., Asnis, P., Griffith, M., Granito, D., Berkson, E. and Gill, T., 2013. Shoulder Instability in Professional Football Players. Sports Health: A Multidisciplinary Approach, 5(5), pp.455-457.
  19. Fakih, R., Hamie, M. and Yassine, M., 2016. Comparative Study on the Management of Glenohumeral Joint Dislocation : Closed Reduction vs. Arthroscopic Remplissage with Bankart Lesion Repair. Lebanese Medical Journal, 64(3), pp.175-180.
  20. Dickens, J., Rue, J., Cameron, K., Tokish, J., Peck, K., Allred, C., Svoboda, S., Sullivan, R., Kilcoyne, K. and Owens, B., 2017. Successful Return to Sport After Arthroscopic Shoulder Stabilization Versus Nonoperative Management in Contact Athletes With Anterior Shoulder Instability: A Prospective Multicenter Study. The American Journal of Sports Medicine, 45(11), pp.2540-2546.
  21. Polyzois, I., Dattani, R., Gupta, R., Levy, O. and Narvani, A., 2016. Traumatic First Time Shoulder Dislocation: Surgery Vs Non-Operative Treatment. [online] PubMed Central (PMC). Available at: <> [Accessed 29 November 2020].
  22. Khiami, F., Gérometta, A. and Loriaut, P., 2015. Management of recent first-time anterior shoulder dislocations. Orthopaedics & Traumatology: Surgery & Research, 101(1), pp.S51-S57.
  23. Van Tongel, A., Rosa, F., Heffernan, G., Levy, O. and Sforza, G., 2011. Long-term result after traumatic anterior shoulder dislocation: what works best?. MUSCULOSKELETAL SURGERY, 95(S1), pp.65-70.
  24. Park, J. and Cosby, N., 2016. Arthroscopic Repair versus Non-operative Treatment of First-time Traumatic Anterior Shoulder Dislocations: A Numbers-needed-to-treat Analysis for Prevention of Recurrent Dislocations. Clinics in Shoulder and Elbow, 19(2), pp.110-116.
  25. Nixon, M., Keenan, O. and Funk, L., 2015. High recurrence of instability in adolescents playing contact sports after arthroscopic shoulder stabilization. Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics B, 24(3), pp.173-177.
  26. Hurley ET, Manjunath AK, Bloom DA, et al. Arthroscopic Bankart Repair Versus Conservative Management for First-Time Traumatic Anterior Shoulder Instability: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Arthroscopy. 2020;36(9):2526-2532. doi:10.1016/j.arthro.2020.04.046
  27. Arliani, G., Astur, D., Cohen, Ejnisman, B., Andreoli, C., Pochini and Carina, D., 2011. Surgical versus nonsurgical treatment in first traumatic anterior dislocation of the shoulder in athletes. Open Access Journal of Sports Medicine, p.19.
  28. Monk, A., Garfjeld Roberts, P., Logishetty, K., Price, A., Kulkarni, R., Rangan, A. and Rees, J., 2013. Evidence in managing traumatic anterior shoulder instability: a scoping review. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 49(5), pp.307-311.

How to Cite

Ardhaswari, M. S. P. P. ., Astawa, P., & Asmara, A. A. G. Y. (2023). Perbandingan penanganan operatif dengan non operatif pada tatalaksana dislokasi bahu anterior terhadap rekurensi: systematic review. Intisari Sains Medis, 14(2), 774–779.




Search Panel

Made Sabrina Prativa Prasaditya Ardhaswari
Google Scholar
ISM Journal

Putu Astawa
Google Scholar
ISM Journal

Anak Agung Gde Yuda Asmara
Google Scholar
ISM Journal